When it comes to finding the best pizza on Anna Maria Island, visitors are in for a treat. This charming barrier island on the Gulf Coast of Florida offers breathtaking natural beauty, a relaxed atmosphere, and a variety of delicious pizzerias to satisfy any craving.
Whether you are staying in one of our vacation rentals on Anna Maria Island or exploring the different cities on the island, you are sure to find a pizza place that will satisfy you.
Anna Maria Island
Located on the Gulf Coast of Florida, Anna Maria is a charming barrier island that captivates visitors with its serene atmosphere and timeless allure. Established in 1893 and named after Anna Maria Cook, the wife of one of the island’s early settlers, this city offers a glimpse into its storied past through its well-preserved architecture and historical landmarks. The Anna Maria City Pier, a beloved fishing spot since the 1910s, allows visitors to soak in breathtaking sunset views while relishing the island’s tranquil ambiance. As you meander through Anna Maria’s Historic District, you’ll be enchanted by its early 20th-century homes and buildings, a testament to the island’s enduring heritage. The city’s recreational offerings cater to a diverse range of interests, from kayaking in the serene waters of Tampa Bay to exploring the pristine beaches that adorn the island’s coastline. For those seeking cultural experiences, the city’s vibrant arts scene adds an extra layer of charm to the island’s allure.
Pizza Social
Pizza Social is a small pizza shop striving to bring the best pizza to Anna Maria Island and the surrounding area. Their specialties include handcrafted pizza and fresh salads. Making dough and tomato-based pizza sauce from scratch is part of the daily routine at Pizza Social. They hand toss and stretch the dough for a nice thin crust and top your pizza with freshly shredded mozzarella cheese, then your pizza is fired up in a 700-degree imported Italian oven and cooked to perfection. While it might take a little longer than your typical takeout spot, the time and extra effort are what makes their pizza taste so much better. They also serve fresh salads to add a healthy option to your indulgent meal.
Holmes Beach
Holmes Beach is a serene retreat based on enchanting Anna Maria Island along Florida’s Gulf Coast, with our Holmes Beach vacation rentals offering the perfect home base for your getaway. Established in 1950 and paying homage to the pioneering Holmes family, this picturesque community seamlessly blends rich history with modern charm, offering discerning individuals a place to get away. Stroll along Holmes Beach’s avenues adorned with historic homes and mid-20th-century architecture, each whispering tales of yesteryears. Delight in the pristine white-sand beaches lining Gulf Drive, where sun-kissed bliss awaits—perfect for sunbathing, swimming, or embarking on a peaceful seashell treasure hunt. For those seeking more active pursuits, indulge in the scenic coastal wonders with rentals of bicycles or paddleboards. Within easy reach lies the Manatee Public Beach, a haven of leisure featuring playful playgrounds and inviting picnic areas for shared moments of joy. A culinary adventure awaits in Bradenton, with options ranging from seafood shacks to refined eateries celebrating local flavors.
Vinny’s Italian Kitchen
Indulge in the soulful flavors of Vinny’s Italian Kitchen, where authentic Italian cuisine is crafted with meticulous care by Chef Vincenzo. Reminiscent of his Italian heritage, each dish has been passed down through generations, exuding rustic charm and traditional artistry. Immerse yourself in a culinary journey through Italy with a menu teeming with almost every Italian classic imaginable, and that means pizza, prepared using only the freshest and finest ingredients. Embark on a journey through Italian cuisine with Vinny’s Italian Kitchen, where every bite promises to transport you to the sun-kissed shores of Italy, leaving you satiated and content in the embrace of authentic Italian flavors.
Bradenton Beach
Step into the vibrant tapestry of Bradenton Beach, located on the southern tip of Anna Maria Island, where our Bradenton Beach vacation rentals offer the perfect way to experience this charming locale. Established in 1952, this coastal gem has evolved into a sought-after destination, blending old-world charm with modern vibrancy. Explore the city’s rich history through iconic landmarks, such as the Bradenton Beach City Pier, a beloved spot for anglers and scenic seekers alike. Admire the classic mid-20th-century architecture that graces the streets, adding a nostalgic touch to the vibrant cityscape. Indulge in the soft, white sands and crystal-clear waters of Gulf Drive, inviting you to bask in moments of pure bliss—whether soaking up the sun, going for a swim, or combing the beaches for treasured seashells. For a day filled with picnics and recreational delights, head to the nearby Coquina Beach, where volleyball courts and playgrounds beckon. Nature lovers can find solace in the Leffis Key Preserve, offering tranquil trails for hiking and bird-watching opportunities amidst the island’s lush landscapes. Meander through the dynamic Bridge Street area, a cultural hub brimming with boutique shops, dining venues, and entertainment options to suit every taste.
Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant
Whether you crave a piping-hot slice of pizza, a plate of al dente pasta, or the fresh catch of the day, Oma’s menu is a tribute to quality and tradition. From the moment you step into Oma’s charming eatery at 201 Gulf Dr N, Bradenton Beach, FL, you are greeted with the warm embrace of Sicilian hospitality and a commitment to culinary excellence. The Mannino family, originating from Sicily, infuses each dish with love and heritage, carrying on a culinary legacy that dates back to 1982 when Oma’s first opened its doors. Whether you opt for indoor dining or wish to enjoy your meal amidst the island breeze with their outdoor seating, Oma’s promises an unforgettable dining experience. Take advantage of Oma’s delivery and takeout services to enjoy a taste of Italy in the comfort of your vacation rental, ensuring that every moment on Anna Maria Island is a culinary delight. Let the flavors of Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant transport you to the heart of Sicily, where every bite tells a story of tradition and authenticity.
Plan Your Visit
Book your Anna Maria Island vacation rental with A Paradise Rentals for a relaxing and memorable getaway. Choose from a wide selection of properties and enjoy your stay on this beautiful island.
Stay With A Paradise Vacation Rentals
No matter which city you find yourself in on Anna Maria Island, you are sure to come across a pizza place that will satisfy your cravings. From Pizza Social in Anna Maria to Vinny’s Italian Kitchen in Holmes Beach and Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant in Bradenton Beach, these pizza spots offer both locals and visitors an opportunity to experience a slice of heaven. So, when you visit Anna Maria Island, make sure to explore the different cities, immerse yourself in the island’s history, and indulge in the best pizza on Anna Maria Island. And while you’re at it, why not enhance your stay by booking one of our vacation rentals on Anna Maria Island? This will allow you to fully experience the island life and make the most of your pizza-filled getaway.
